Disease & Politics Combine to Threaten Our Deer Hunting Heritage

cwd wisconsin - chronic wasting disease

When I began deer hunting, Wisconsin’s archery license cost me one dollar, winter kill took more deer than hunters did, and wolves were considered extinct in this state. Back then, the DNR was an independent agency assigned to look after the welfare of Wisconsin’s natural resources. They were not controlled by the governor. To find deer you headed north since southern Wisconsin’s deer population was sparse, with some counties having no open season. Things were about to change. In the eighties and nineties, winters became milder rendering winter kill the exception rather than the norm. Deer herds grew and expanded statewide, hunters killed record amounts of deer. An unforeseen storm lay just ahead, though, in the form of politics and disease.

Wisconsin buck pole

Times were good for deer hunters prior to the turn of the century, but a black cloud was on the horizon.

In the nineties, then governor Tommy Thompson mandated the DNR would now report to the governor who would from then on assert political control over them. Enter politics. No longer would Wisconsin have a group of independent professionals managing our natural resources, politicians would now control its fate.

In 2002, Chronic Wasting Disease paid us a visit and is now in the process of devastating our deer population. Politics and a disease with no cure in sight have  combined to take us into a period of uncertainty with regards as to how to save our deer herd. A bad storm is brewing and the captain is losing control of the ship. Dr. James Kroll, a well respected biologist was appointed Deer Czar by Scott Walker to cure the ills of a hunting public who have grown weary of a DNR that have been seen as ineffective in handling the management of our deer herd. The same DNR that Scott Walker and all the other governors going back to Tommy Thompson have been responsible for. Dr. Kroll and his committee came up with many recommendations for managing our deer, among them was a warning that scientific research was crucial to combating CWD. Our governor has opted to ignore this advice and has decided to cut DNR staff scientist positions and reduce funding with regards to CWD related efforts. Scientific research is seen by many as the only hope in stopping the advance of CWD but our governor has thrown in the towel just when we need him to increase both funding and research if we have any hope of winning this battle.

Over half the counties in Wisconsin are dealing with CWD, which is on the rise and will surely spill over into the backyards of the rest sooner, rather than later. In 2002, we tested 40,000 deer for the disease. In 2015, we tested around 3100. Despite decreased testing due to budget cutbacks, the DNR has determined that CWD prevalence in the core area of Dane and Iowa counties has gone from 8% to 25% in adult bucks. Expect that number to go to 50% or higher in a few years in the core area with the remainder of the state headed in that direction in the near future. CWD is always fatal so we’re dealing with a disease that will devastate the herd. Is the governor cutting back on CWD funding in hopes that testing will vanish and the hunting public will not hear the bad news? Why is he not listening to the man he hired as Deer Czar and put more funding and effort into doing more research? We, the hunting public, cannot allow our legislators to bury their heads in the sand while CWD wipes out our deer herd. They must fund research to find a cure for CWD if we have any hope of passing on our deer hunting heritage to our children. Politicians wanted control over the DNR and took it twenty years ago, now they must be held responsible for seeing to it the DNR has the tools and support to fight CWD.

1 Comment

  1. Josh Leffel

    It sounds like Wisconsin is adopting the same type of deer herd management as we deal with here in Indiana. It is going on here as well. The DNR do not have the right to manage our deer herd with science as they used to. The politicians now control the management of our deer herd. They have decimated our herd by allowing very liberal doe quotas in places that simply cannot withstand it, they allow an extremely long gun season, they allow a late doe only season, and for this year, they have decided to allow high powered rifles, even though the DNR and the NRC and voted against it. The Governor simply pushed it through. These are the end times for deer seasons as i see it. Its time for hunters to do the right thing, as our politicians are only concerned with making insurance companies and special interest groups on the sides of big farmers, happy.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *