I'm looking at getting either a slug barrel for my 12g Rem. 870 or a .45-70 for my TC Encore (or lever action). This will be used in a "short range" weapons hunt in my state for cow elk, as well as a stand/blind rifle in thick timbered areas for bucks (100yrds or less). Ballistics look similar (depending on the slug) between the 12g & .45-70.
This idea came up as I was archery hunting elk in an area that allowed a short range weapon for cows (short range in Idaho is bow, muzzleloader, shotgun, or any center fire "pistol" cartridge). I didn't want to pack my smoke pole (weight) AND my bow, but had several oppertunities at cows within 100 yards but out of bow range.
Joined: Fri May 13, 2005 12:16 pm Posts: 975 Location: WI
I think cost wise you're going to have more into the .45-70 and it's going to be heavier than the 870 where I would be inclined to use the muzzleloader. I've shot both in the past but think of the 870 as a little closer range gun than 100yds, more like 75-80yds but maybe that is just my lack of shooting ability.
I believe this issue is mostly a matter of preference. As mentioned, ballistics are quite similar, with the .45-70 probably delivering just a tad better accuracy at 100 yds. Since a rifled slug barrel is all that is needed to turn the 870 into an effective close range hunting set-up, that is the rout I would take. I can't imagine shooting effectively in thick/dense terrain more than 75 yards.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum